By Sandra Cohen & Louis Akra
We have written on this subject before, including on why a stock option plan needs a tune-up ahead of an initial public offering (IPO) and on how to meet the stock plan needs of a newly public company. Here, we build on those posts by returning to a more fundamental point: when a privately-held company becomes publicly-held, typically through an IPO, what changes is not only who owns the business but how it must be run, governed and held to account.
Equity incentive plans for privately-held companies are largely exempt from SEC public disclosure rules and do not have to broadcast their financials to the general public. Publicly-held companies, however, are under heavy and continuous scrutiny, including from a massive and diverse group of investors. It is therefore very important that a private company’s equity incentive plans be properly structured for an IPO.
Choosing the Right Type of Equity Award
The right equity award depends largely on where a company is in its life cycle. Private companies commonly begin with time-vested stock options, may add time-vested RSUs as they mature and, once public, frequently also use performance stock units (PSUs) to further align executive performance with public stakeholders. To accommodate more than one award type, a company may establish a new omnibus equity incentive plan, which serves as an umbrella plan with an approved stock pool and a centralized administrative framework, allowing issuance of multiple types of awards under a single plan.
For private companies, time-vested stock options are a commonly used form of equity compensation, offering considerable upside potential and flexibility because a larger number of shares are normally granted compared to other award types, such as restricted stock units (RSUs). To be valid and compliant under Section 409A, options must be granted with an exercise price at or above the fair market value of the underlying stock on the grant date. As the IPO draws nearer in timing, many issuers cease granting options because their past 409A valuations might be stale or relying on a prior valuation, too close to the public offering might no longer be reasonable. Or they are concerned that the IPO pricing might be too much in flux to be certain that the exercise price is a secure 409A safe harbor price. For that reason, among others, an RSU grant, which does not require a valuation at the time of grant, is more popular equity award for pre-IPO companies.
Restricted Stock Units (and their close cousins, performance stock units) are also granted with some regularity, particularly as a company matures. Unlike an early-stage private company, a mature company sees its stock price eventually begin to level off, and because RSUs represent actual shares of stock, these awards continue to hold real value for employees even if the share price dips. PSUs vest only if pre-established performance targets, such as EBITDA or total shareholder return, are achieved and certified, which is why they are more common in mature companies, where long-term goals are easier to set, than in fast-moving early-stage ones. Whichever awards a company selects, public-company status adds a further consideration: the plan, and the targets within it, must also satisfy shareholders and the proxy advisory firms that guide them, as discussed below.
Preventing Questionable Pay Practices
As noted above, a public company's equity plan does not rest on the company's judgment alone. Public companies are generally required to obtain shareholder authorization to establish a new equity compensation plan, to amend an existing plan or to increase the number of shares reserved under an existing plan. Proxy advisory firms, including Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) and Glass Lewis, make recommendations to investors on these proposals and on other corporate governance matters, and many public companies therefore design their equity plans with the ISS and Glass Lewis guidelines in mind.
Similarly, when evaluating a plan for a say on pay vote, ISS and Glass Lewis will score the equity incentive plans of public companies against its own list of problematic pay practices. While examining the problematic pay practices is beyond the scope of this article, an issuer contemplating a public offering should review these lists with their advisors and consider whether to adjust any components of the private company’s total executive pay packages before they are subject to this kind of attention from professional investors.
By designing pay packages and plans to align long-term performance with shareholder value, an executive compensation advisor can successfully help companies avoid negative recommendations from these proxy advisors.
Compensation Disclosures
Under existing SEC rules, there are executive compensation disclosure requirements contained in Item 402 of Regulation S-K that provide for comprehensive and detailed compensation transparency. On November 13, 2026, the SEC issued proposed new rules that would considerably simplify such compensation disclosures, including by reducing compliance burdens for public companies where there is not corresponding benefit for investors and providing public companies with more flexibility to present their disclosures in a way that is consistent with how compensation programs are generally constructed today. While these new simpler rules will not take effect for the 2027 proxy season, public issuers, and businesses preparing for an IPO, should keep them on their radar, as the changes would overhaul their future reporting obligations. The SEC has opened a 60-day public comment period on the proposal.
Navigating Compliance
Newly public companies may encounter legal issues that will need to be considered by the plan:
Code Section 409A - if the plan permits equity awards that are non-qualified deferred compensation, then Section 409A requires a written provision addressing the required six-month delay upon a separation from service for public-company specified employees.
Exchange Act Section 16(b) –addresses short-swing profit liability and prohibits company directors, officers and beneficial owners of more than 10% of a registered class of the company's equity securities (or “statutory insiders”) from purchasing and selling (or selling and purchasing) a company’s equity securities within a rolling 6-month period.
Code Section 162(m) – limits the federal income tax deduction for compensation paid to each covered employee to $1 million per year. Covered employees include the CEO, the CFO and other highly-paid executive officers. After someone becomes a covered employee, that person remains a covered employee each year thereafter, even if the employee leaves the company (referred to as “once in, always in”).
Authority of Plan Administrators – prior to delegating administrative authority, we advise verifying securities exchange listing requirements, company organizational documents and state corporate law for limitations on delegations.
International Considerations – local tax and securities laws in each country can determine which types of awards are used, as well as foreign governance rules that might affect required shareholder approvals and disclosures for equity awards.
Given that the shift from a private company to a public company creates new challenges and obstacles in how a business compensates its employees, it is important that private companies consider how best to structure their equity plans to align with public market standards, proxy advisor expectations and global governance and regulatory rules. The time to do so is before the IPO, while the company still has flexibility over its award types, plan terms and executive pay packages. We encourage any company contemplating a public offering to review its equity incentive plans with counsel and its executive compensation advisors well in advance, so that the plans it carries into the public markets are built to withstand the scrutiny that will follow.
Sandra W. Cohen is the Managing Partner and Co-Founder of Cohen & Buckmann P.C. She advises companies and executives on executive compensation, equity incentive plans and employment arrangements.
Louis Akra is an Associate at Cohen & Buckmann P.C., where he advises on executive compensation and employment matters. He received his J.D. from Cornell Law School and previously practiced at Debevoise & Plimpton LLP.